As much trouble President Bush is having getting traction for Social Security reform, he may have even a tougher road with his ideas for immigration reform if border security concerns in congress continues to rise. Lou Dobbs in this
US News & World Report column says immigration control in congress is growing.
The president rationalizes his guest-worker program by constantly referring to the nation's need to match willing workers with willing employers. The American people disagree. A USA Today /CNN/Gallup poll shows only 34 percent of those surveyed approve of President Bush's immigration policies. For an example of potential "guest workers" see
The Immigration Blog post
MEET THE "GUEST WORKERS" from yesterday.
Bush's lackluster attitude towards border securitiy is difficult to understand at best. Last week when he met with Mexican President Vicente Fox and Canadian Prime Minister Paul Martin,
Bush said speaking of the Arizona Minutemen,
"I'm against vigilantes in the United States of America," Mr. Bush said at a joint press conference. "I'm for enforcing the law in a rational way."
But there is nothing rational about calling good concerned American citizens "vigilantes". I don't know who the President is listening to, probably one of the
opposition smear campaigns, but the Minutemen are not "vigilantes," and Bush's characterization is blatently wrong. They have in fact pledged not to confront anyone, but instead to observe only, and call the Border Patrol when they spot crossings.
What they are doing is trying to have an effect on border security—something that he so far has refused to do. Yet it appears that many of our elected officials are finally grasping the importance border security. Whether they are comming around out of real concern for national security or because of pressure from the American people isn't clear to me, but I'll not complain either way. Secure borders our top legislative priority.
Lou Dobbs column lays out the situation pretty clear along with his opinions for reform of momentous significance to controling our borders.
"The American people don't want open borders; they don't want amnesty," says Rep. Tom Tancredo, a Colorado Republican. "It's a message that is beginning to get through to the Congress. We've just got to get it through to the president."
That message has gotten through to one of the administration's most cheerful and energetic loyalists on Capitol Hill, Rep. David Dreier of California. After ignoring the realities of illegal immigration for nearly all of his long tenure in Congress, Republican Dreier now says he will introduce legislation to stop American businesses from hiring illegal aliens, using a photo-embedded Social Security card, which employers would be required to check with a national database to determine whether the job applicant is legal or illegal.
It is not clear whether Rep. Dreier is serious about border control or is just looking for a more palatable bill that would, as Dobbs believes, likely just be ignored by most employers and illegal immigrants.
Lou Dobbs goes on to say that; "These shameless border games must end," and has excelent ideas for reform.
That reform, in my opinion, begins at our borders. Here's what real reform should entail: No matter how much money or manpower is required, we must be able to control the flow of people and goods across our borders and through our ports. We must exact heavy penalties on businesses, large and small, as well as individuals who hire illegal aliens. Not only do illegal aliens cost the nations tens of billions of dollars in social services, principally in healthcare and education, but they depress wages for American citizens by an estimated $200 billion a year. American business is exploiting cheap labor and paradoxically doing so with the blessing and support of national unions.
Skipping taxes. The burden of our failed immigration and homeland security policies, if they can be called policies, falls crushingly on working men and women in the form of higher taxes, lower wages, and an all but total lack of representation by the government they support through their votes and tax dollars. An estimated 6 million illegal aliens work in the underground economy, where neither they nor those who employ them pay taxes. That accounts for part of an additional $400 billion a year in taxes that should be paid to the Internal Revenue Service. Once again, the middle class is under assault by a government that is functioning as if it had never heard of the Declaration of Independence or the Constitution.
Dobbs closing thought is that if the Dreier proposal is given precedence over Sensenbrenner's, it will be a clear indication of whether the House and Senate will represent the national interest, or continue serving special interest with their votes. He is spot on.
President Bush's proposals for immigration reform are wrong and costly to taxpayers. His policies for border control (if any) are woefully inept and dangerous.