Skinning: Wordpress • Invision • Expression Engine • phpBB3
Fisking the "good news in Iraq is not news"
by Sandi
 
The other day I posted on one of my news forum haunts about an article in the Chicago Tribune. The article was about life returning to normal in Baghdad since the "Surge." Not surprising, I got the usual negative comments from the usual suspects about how meaningless the good news really is. A few examples:
  • "...a large part is due to completion of an initiative to segregate Sunnis and Shia in walled off and gated neighborhoods or districts"

  • "Baghdad is a very small part of a very large nation."

  • "Progress?? Some headway toward a problem that was a direct result of poor planning by the Bush admin and I'm supposed to call it progress??"

  • "Unfortunately, the bad seems to outweigh the good with this 'war.'"

But as one of the few posters who consider the news good said: "Democrats who pronounced the war lost are in a tough spot."

That's certainly true; not that all Democrats call the war lost, but a few have. Now the New York Times—certainly not a paper to hold a pro-war or a pro-surge view in the past—is conceding to success, and a lot of it at that. But then consider, once the handwriting is on the wall it is not a good idea to keep ones head in the sand either; not if one wants to avoid that "tough spot."

This isn't just one article, or two in the Times, but six (count them six), articles by three different authors. These articles each look at a different aspect of Iraqi life that has recently returned to normal. (just short excerpts so read the articles)

Weddings:

These days, marriages are back, in public and in some cases, after dark. Mr. Muhammad's shop has reopened. And at a photo studio in western Baghdad recently, three young happy couples appeared for portraits, arriving with an entourage and bands in tow. The brides and grooms ascended a long line of stairs to get their pictures taken in front of landscapes depicting pastoral gardens, sunsets or even an American-style suburban home with a white picket fence.

....

None perhaps were happier than Rifaat al-Haliji, 32, one of the bandleaders who arrived with a couple from Allawi, a neighborhood close by. After Ramadan ended last month, he said that business started to increase.

"We were stuck out of work for seven months," he said. Now, he added, "we do five weddings a week."


Restaurants:

Now things are a little better. Customer come at 4 p.m. and leave at 11 p.m.

"You be the judge," said one cook, Ali Abu Hussain.

A few hundred yards north on a sealed-off stretch of the riverbank a dozen long-closed restaurants stand poised to reopen. Owners refurbished the dilapidated cafes using American dollars pumped into what American and Iraqi officials trumpeted as a showpiece renovation of the city's historic Abu Nawas Boulevard.


Zawra Park:

"Gardens are the paradise of God on earth," reads the sign welcoming an ever-growing but still cautious group of pleasure-seekers visiting Baghdad's largest public park, beside the Green Zone. Beneath trees and models of traditional Marsh Arab and Bedouin homes, picnicking families sit in clusters chatting and sipping Alpha Cola, against a backdrop of police sirens and shots from outside — some perhaps in anger, but mostly armored Blackwater-style convoys forcing their way through traffic jams. Some families are here for the first time in years.


Computer Street:

Some have trickled back to Baghdad after fleeing to Jordan or Syria. Others had no electricity in their homes to go online.

With the improvements in security, there is also increased demand for equipment. Customer numbers are up 20 percent for Nazar Nazaryan, a laser printing specialist, with much of the demand coming from government ministries.


Theater:

The entire room rose in a wave to sing: "My country, my country, glory and beauty and delight is in your land. Safety, prosperity and hope is in your air."

There was no curtain, no set beyond a chair, a long rope and an Iraqi flag, which would soon be used as a shroud. But the piece, written and performed by students at Baghdad's Fine Arts Institute and sponsored by the Young People Union, an allegory with more mime than words, needed no more to be understood.

A painter smiles as he depicts all that is beautiful in Iraq; a small singing bird keeps him company until bombs begin to fall. The painter drops his brush and cowers, the bird flies away. People die in the street. An Iraqi politician in a snazzy suit appears. He is tied by a long rope to a man dressed in an American military uniform. The painter weeps as he watches the politician raise his arms like a marionette when the American tugs at him. Iraqis, tribal sheiks and workmen, painters and bodyguards, attack one another with cardboard daggers and guns.


Liquor Store:

On Thursday evenings now, before the Muslim holy day, men in long white garments and tribal head scarfs squeeze elbow to elbow with men in western T-shirts to scrutinize the shelves of dark shops lined with bottles of cheap whiskey, Dutch beer and Turkish arak.

They walk away now their heads held high, swinging their purchases in plastic bags. On a recent evening several men crowded near a small shop that was little more than a large pair of shutters halfway up the wall of a house. The shopkeepers leaned out the window and passed bottles across the ledge to waiting customers.

Such a scene would not have occurred even four months ago. Both the Shiite Mahdi militia, with ties to anti-American cleric Moktada al-Sadr, and extremist Sunni groups viewed liquor as a sin and bombed stores that sold it and threatened the owners. Christians were most often the victims since they owned the majority of liquor shops — there is no prohibition on selling alcohol in Christian teaching, although some Christian groups eschew it.

Tell me again now how bad life really is in Iraq.

Via Dean's World, thanks Dean.

Posted Tuesday November 20, 2007 | Catagory: (Good news (WOT)) | Permalink
0 Comments | 0 Trackbacks
Sunni, Shia Sheiks United Against al-Qaeda
by Sandi
 
Good news from Iraq is always refreshing.

A short-notice reconciliation meeting of regional sheiks with potential for impact throughout Iraq was held Nov. 8 in Al Bassam, an area approximately 16 kilometers west of Baghdad city center.

The conference was called by a highly influential leader, Abu Maruf, with less than 24-hours notice, to make a public declaration of unity amongst the tribes against al-Qaeda and to map the way ahead for their region.

....

Members of more than 30 tribes attended the conference; both Sunnis and Shias were represented. Their differences were set aside for the day as they publicly united with one voice and vowed to fight al-Qaeda and work toward a lasting peace for their region.

Maruf facilitated the conference and announced the formation of the Baghdad Brigade which will provide support to the region stretching from Yusufiyah to Taji. The brigade will consist of not only military elements, but also be the umbrella organization for their socio-political initiatives.

Some Mulit-National forces were also invited. Lt. Col. Brian Coppersmith saw the unity as an indicator of better things to come.

More than 350 officials of varying ranks and positions within their tribes were present to participate in the conference. In addition to the public declarations of unity, the tribal sheiks declared their support for a representative government and council members were voted on immediately following the speeches. Meetings with key ministries of the government of Iraq have been scheduled for the near future.


Posted Tuesday November 13, 2007 | Catagory: (Good news (WOT)) | Permalink
0 Comments | 0 Trackbacks
Is It Dumb Luck, Or The Surge?
by Sandi
 
Bill Ardolino takes a look at the reduction in violence in Iraq.

The drop began in September, as civilian deaths (884) fell 52 percent from August and 77 percent year-over-year, while military deaths (65) fell 23 percent and 10 percent over the same periods. October’s declines made it a trend: Civilian deaths (758) dropped an additional 12 percent from the previous month and 38 percent year-over-year, while US military deaths (38) dropped 42 percent and 64 percent during the same periods.

"Is it the surge, is it just dumb luck, or are there a series of factors that all contribute towards the lessening violence in Iraq?" asked General Terry Wolff, the Special Assistant to the President and Senior Director for Iraq and Afghanistan Policy Implementation on the National Security Council, in a conference call last Friday. Wolff and other senior military and intelligence officials offered a list of "complementary" factors theorized to have reduced the violence in interviews with The Long War Journal.

“The Surge” and counterinsurgency tactics

Top US officials are quick to point out the effect of the increase of US personnel on the reduction of violence, citing an acquired ability to target a wider range of al Qaeda and Shiite militia extremists and to project security into new areas with a focus on protecting civilians.

“[There are] two key threats out there. [C]learly al Qaeda is the large near-term threat. They’re the folks doing the car bombings, the mass killings, and you’ve also got the “Special Groups,” also known as the militant Shia splinter groups,” said Air Force Colenol Donald Bacon, Chief of Strategy and Plans, Strategic Communications at Multinational Force Iraq. “Fact is, we’re having some success in both areas and that’s equated to these better trends.”

H/T to Dave Price at Deans World

Posted Thursday November 8, 2007 | Catagory: (Good news (WOT)) | Permalink
0 Comments | 0 Trackbacks
Thanks and Praise
by Sandi
 
Michael Yon has videotaped Muslims and Christians rejoicing and working together placing a cross atop the St. John’s Church in Baghdad. Michael is making the

A Muslim man had invited the American soldiers from “Chosen” Company 2-12 Cavalry to the church, where I videotaped as Muslims and Christians worked and rejoiced at the reopening of St John’s, an occasion all viewed as a sign of hope.

The Iraqis asked me to convey a message of thanks to the American people. ” Thank you, thank you,” the people were saying. One man said, “Thank you for peace.” Another man, a Muslim, said “All the people, all the people in Iraq, Muslim and Christian, is brother.” The men and women were holding bells, and for the first time in memory freedom rang over the ravaged land between two rivers. (Videotape to follow.)

The video isn't up yet, but check out Michael Yon's great picture. He is making it available to media outlets for a limited time, but I wouldn't hold my breath waiting to a few of them to publish it.

Posted Thursday November 8, 2007 | Catagory: (Good news (WOT)) | Permalink
0 Comments | 0 Trackbacks